US Submarines ~ Pre WWI Submarines ~ WWI Submarines ~ Post WWI Submarines ~ 1920's Submarines ~ 1930's Submarines ~ Submarines in 1940
A - F Boats G - O Boats R - V Boats Fleet Boats More Sub Stuff PigBoats.COM™ Research Papers  
'... The Navy's best are found upon; The pigboats black and trim; For men must be of sturdy stuff; To sink and still to swim ...'

The F-Boats

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The photo above was taken at San Diego circa 1913 showing three of the four "F" class submarines and the Submarine Tender USS Alert, AS-4. The F-2 and F-1 are the two outboard submarines. The names F-2 and F-1 are seen on the bows. The third, or inboard boat, is the F-3.

This is known from the name of the submarine being placed aft of the bow planes and barely visible in extreme magnification in this photo. The shape of the bow planes fairings, another clue, which are narrower, not having the upper and lower slanted top and bottom as the F-1 and F-2 but having the bottom and top having horizontal surfaces instead as did the F-3 and F-4. The difference between the two building yards building styles.

The F-4 had been plagued by numerous faults and mechanical failures and equipment shortages since her building and was even delayed her leaving Seattle with the F-3 to join her sisters in San Francisco and later San Pedro for these reasons. She is still not with the "F-fleet", as they were called, as of the date on this photo taken, most likely, in early 1913.

The F-1 and 2 were built at Union Iron Works in the San Francisco area. The F-3 and 4 were built in Seattle. The F-1 and F-2 had the names placed on the bows. The F-3 and F-4 had the names placed aft of the bow planes, as will be seen in other photos in this archive. Again this is the difference between the building yards. The name placement was later standardized to all the F class having the names on the bows but not until after the "F fleet" had assembled and headed to Hawaii. The Alert went with the submarines to Hawaii.

The New York Sun newspaper reported on January 10, 1913, "...the tender USS Alert and the submarines F-1, F-2 and F-3 were at San Diego...". Another report places them en-route to San Diego on the 13th. That may be the general time frame of this photo.

Other newspapers reported on April 6th and again on April 29th, 1913, that the submarine tender USS Alert and the submarines F-1, F-2 and F-3 were at San Pedro. No mention of the F-4 arriving yet.

The F-2, the left hand boat, is doing a battery charge by running her starboard engine. The exhaust can be seen billowing out from her stern in the photo.

Photo in the Private Collection of Ric Hedman


USS F-4 , F-2, F-3 and F-1
USS F-4 , F-2, F-3 and F-1 and crews photographed in Hawaii in 1914.

The four F-boats in Honolulu
The four F-boats docked in Honolulu Harbor, date unknown, July 1914 to March 1915.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

A very commonly reproduced photo of the USS F-2, F-1 and the ill-fated F-4 moored, most likely, at Pier 5A in Honolulu Harbor. The photo was taken after the arrival of the F-Class submarines in Hawaii in the July of 1914 and the March 25, 1915 sinking of the F-4. The four F-Boats were towed to Hawaii by the cruisers South Dakota and West Virginia.

The flat land area seen in the background is Sand Island. The building/lighthouse seen on the left is marking the inner entrance channel to the harbor and is called the Honolulu Harbor Light Station. On the right the large building is the Quarantine Docks where ships from over seas were moored until cleared by the health inspectors. When the F-4 was finally raise after her sinking, that took the lives of all her crew, her first stop was at these docks still hanging from chains under the lifting pontoons while a dry dock was made available.

Pearl Harbor at this time was mainly a coaling station for larger ships and the submarine base there wasn't ready until 1920 so the submarine fleet moored normally at Piers 5 & 5A near the entrance to Honolulu Harbor.

US Navy Photo


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

All four "F" Class submarine moored to the tender USS Alert in Honolulu Harbor, circa early 1915. The F-4 sank on March 25, 1915. This might be one of the last known F-4 photos prior to her loss with all hands. The USS Alert arrived in Hawaii in early 1915 in company with four K-Class submarines.

The ship aft of the Alert is the German Unprotected Cruiser SMS Geier that was being pursued by Japanese and British Navy ships had taken shelter in the neutral port of Honolulu. Claiming engine problems she needed repair parts from Germany which she couldn't get she was more or less stranded there until the US entered the war and seized the Geier renaming her USS Schurz and placed into American service for the war effort.

Being a neutral port had restrictions on what information could be reported and the Germans and Japanese claimed the US had violated this when a radio station in Honolulu had reported the Geier's presence in Honolulu. The Navy censer had been not been there at the time. This caused all sorts of international problems. As it turned out later the Geier, her radio room having been sealed by the US, had broken the room seals and had transmitted messages that ran into legal battles even after WW I had ended.

Photo provided by Rick Larson MMCM(SS) (ret.).


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

This really nice portrait of the four F-Class submarines was taken in Honolulu Harbor circa 1915 between the Navy Docks 5 and 5A. Photo looks to have been taken at about mid-day by the sun angles.

Looking at the mooring sequence of the submarines and the other vessels in the photo we are fairly positive this photo was taken at the same time as the one shown just above but from directly in front of the submarines. This goes down to including the man sitting on a chair on the deck of the USS F-1. The numerical order of the vessels is the same as above. ( Left to Right, F-2, F-3, F-4, F-1 ). The tender the submarines are moored to is identical to the vessel in the previous photo, the USS Alert.

Though the names on the hull are indistinct on a few submarines the shape of the bow planes pivot covers help separate the vessels into where each was built. The two outer submarines have covers with sloping top and bottoms and were built at Union Iron Works in San Francisco. (F1 and F-2). The two middle submarines have covers with flat tops and bottoms and were built at Seattle Construction and Dry Dock in Seattle, Washington. (F-3 and F-4) These features remained the same through their whole careers.

Though this is a really great image of the four F Class Submarines, the real interesting story is taking place just behind them.

The vessel seen astern of the Alert is the German Unprotected Cruiser SMS Geier, as seen in other photos. After the US entered WW I the Geier was seized by the US and pressed into service as the USS Schurz. She later sank in a ramming on the US east coast.

The vessel on the left is thought to be the German steamship Locksun (ex-German SS Andree Rickmers), that had been pressed into service as a collier for the Geier. She took refuge a day or so later than the German Cruiser from the Japanese Cruiser Hizen blockading the German ships. Locksun was not an interned ship at first because her connection with Geier was not known at first.

Locksun even took prisoners from the sunk German power schooner Aeolus from Hizen and brought them aboard the Locksun. Once her connection was known she was interned as well. After the US entered the war she was renamed the USS Gulfport AK-5 and remained in US service until 1922.

Interesting to note as soon as the US entered WW I all interned ships in US ports around the world tried to destroy their engines and or scuttle the ships in harbors to block them. Geier set fire to her engine room and boilers. Locksun damaged her engines.

Directly behind the USS F-3, (second from left) can be seen the Honolulu Harbor Light Station lighthouse on Sand Island. On the deck of the F-3 there is a crewman lounging with his back leaning against the conning tower fairwater in the shade.

Photo in the collection of Ric Hedman.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

This wonderful photo comes to us from a contributor in the Netherlands. The photo shows the USS F-1 and the USS F-3 moored to what is probably Navy Pier 5. There is a third submarine at the far left but not enough is seen to know if this is the USS F-2 or the ill-fated F-4. With this unknown it is hard to date the photo though with the crane being so prominent it is a good guess to say it is most likely post March 25, 1915 and pre November 1915 when the F-Class were towed to the mainland.

The Floating Crane, YD-25, is seen in the background. Efforts to raise the F-4 first utilised this crane but she proved too heavy.

Note the shape difference in the fairings over the bow plane mechanism. The F-1 and F-2 were built at Union Iron Works in San Francisco and the F-3 and F-4 were built in Seattle and Seattle Construction and Dry Dock. Just subtle differences in building styles.

Most interestingly is the ship moored at the far right in the photo. This is the interred German unprotected cruiser SMS Geier of the Bussard class. The Geier in need of engine repairs and coal to fuel her boilers put into the neutral United States port at Honolulu, Hawaii in October 1914. Unable to get the parts from Germany to repair the engines she remained at Honolulu where she was eventually interred.

After the American entrance into the war in April 1917, the US Navy seized Geier, commissioned her as USS Schurz, and placed her on convoy duty. She was ultimately sunk following a collision with a freighter off the coast of North Carolina, with one man killed and twelve injured. She rests at a depth of 115 feet.

The Geier was armed with ten 4.1 inch guns, one of which can be seen just below and to the left of the lifeboat. The German Naval Ensign is flying from the stern. When the still submerged hulk of the F-4 was towed into the harbor the Geier along with all the other ships in harbor lowered her flag to half mast in tribute.

Photo Contributed By Erik van Gemst From The Netherlands


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

This interesting photo was most likely taken in late March or April of 1915, during the salvage operations for the USS F-4. The location is Honolulu Harbor, TH. The large derrick in the background is the Navy floating crane YD-25. Normally employed for construction activities at the brand new base under construction at Pearl Harbor, the crane had been moved to Honolulu to support the F-4 salvage. Unfortunately the sub proved to be too heavy for the crane so lifting pontoons ultimately had to be used.

The two submarines in the foreground are (left to right, despite what the caption says) the F-3 and the F-1. Whether this photo was taken before or after the one above in unknown. There are at least several days between the two images. The location of the crane has moved slightly and there is a difference in the waterline levels of the two submarines. This photo is a little ironic in that just two years later, during night maneuvers off the coast of San Diego, these two boats would collide in the darkness, resulting in the loss of the F-1 and nineteen of her crew.

Seen just to the immediate right of the pipe frame for the F-1 bridge tarpaulins, peeking over the crane barge deck, is the cupola for the Honolulu Harbor Light House with the smaller lantern on its top. To the left side of the F-1 Bridge Fairwater is an F-1 Sailor. He is seen standing behind the Torpedo loading ramp.

The large ship in the left background is the German collier SS Locksun that was to supply coal to the German raider SMS Geier. They entered Honolulu several days apart and were not known immediately to be connected. When the US entered WW I the ship and its valuable cargo of coal was seized and commissioned into the USN as the USS Gulfport. She was decommissioned sold in 1922.

Note the confusion of the person hand printing, backwards, with white ink on the negative, trying to make the letters look correct.

Photo In The Private Collection Of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The three remaining F class submarines after the sinking of the USS F-4. They are moored at the Navy Piers in Honolulu Harbor on what appears to be a clam sunny morning. Before the trade winds pick-up it can be hot and humid there. The lighthouse on Sand Island can be seen in the background. The crews are cleaning the submarines up for a Captains Inspection. The three submarines were prohibited from diving after the pressure hull collapsed on the F-4 from corrosion caused by a battery acid leak killing all 19 crew. A group of 5 or 6 young men sit and watch the activity. Probably curious about submarines in the wake of the F-4's sinking. The submarines were later towed back to the mainland being replaced by the newer and more reliable K class submarines.

Photo in the collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

A closer look at the USS F-1 and F-3 moored at the Navy Piers in Honolulu Harbor. The crews are cleaning the submarines up for a Captains Inspection. The three remaining submarines were prohibited from diving after the pressure hull collapsed on the F-4 from corrosion caused by a battery acid leak killing all 19 crew. There appears to be a coaling station on a pier in the background. The bow of the F-2 can be seen at the extream right.

Photo in the collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Moored aft of the F-1 and F-3 is the USS F-2. A group of sailors take shelter from the morning sun in the shade of the fairwater on the F-3. The lighthouse on Sand Island can be seen in the background.

Photo in the collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

A group of young men caught in the moment watching the submarines. It would be interesting to know what they thought of those submarines and men sailing them.

Photo in the collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

In this photo are the remaining submarines of the "F Flotilla" of Hawaii after the sinking of the USS F-4. They are, left to right, the USS F-1, USS F-2 and USS F-3. They are moored to Pier 5 in Honolulu Harbor. The Armored Cruiser Maryland is moored at the left to pier 5A.

The date is in question since Maryland was at Honolulu several times during this 1915 time frame. One was bringing the six specially made pontoons used to raise the USS F-4 from the ocean floor just off Honolulu Harbor. Later she had help tow the replacement "K" class submarines to Hawaii. She later towed the F-3 back to California. The collier Nanshan and the tug Iroquois towed the F-l and the F-2 respectively. The presence of the three F craft narrows the timing. We believe this photo is the earlier visit after transporting the pontoons.

A crowd of Maryland sailors are on deck looking over the little submarines out of curiosity. Submarines were still far and few from being a common sight, even in Navy ports. Probably because of the recent sinking of the F-4 and because, too, their having just transported her salvage pontoons on their deck. There are 6 sailors in whites, two on F-2, four on F-1 that may be visiting from the Maryland curious to see what a submarine is all about.

The F-3 has forward tanks emptied and aft trim probably flooded to have so much of an up angle. Her bow much higher than her sisters' bows. No doubt there being considerable maintenance being done to these submarines in lieu of the F-4 sinking. Partly in trying to determine what happened to the F-4 and prevent another such accident.

The three remaining submarines were prohibited from diving until they had all been thoroughly overhauled and re-certified. To do this they needed to be returned to the mainland. Their overhauls to be completed at Mare Island Naval Shipyard.

In the background, bisected by the F-3 periscopes, is the Honolulu Harbor Light Station on Sand Island marking the inner end of the harbor entrance channel. There is a similar view taken from the same dock on the arrival of the "K Flotilla" that replaced the F class.

In 1915 the well known Naval Station Pearl Harbor was in it's infancy. Major work was still going on to build the facility and a large amount of dredging still needed to be done to the shallow harbor. Because of this, most naval activity in Hawaii was centered in Honolulu Harbor, down the coast to the east a few miles.

A recreational canoe is seen resting on the pier. Maybe something for men to do on off hours. There appears to be a rounded skeg attached to the bottom of the canoes' keel blocking part of the view of the F-3. This may be a sailing canoe of some type.

Photo in the collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Three unidentified F-Class submarines, most likely at Mare Island for inspection and repair. After the sinking of the F-4 the remaining F-Class boats were ordered back to the mainland to be examined and repaired and overhauled before they would be permitted to dive again.

The right hand submarine has had panels removed from both sides of its conning tower fairwater, exposing all the systems with in it. She also has a deck plate propped up to access equipment with-in the superstructure.

The middle and left hand submarines have had the superstructure removed over their engine mufflers and exhausts for some sort of maintenance. We imagine that a combination of heat and saltwater was a recipe for corrosion.

Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.


USS F-1
Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The yet to be commissioned Submarine Carp, (future USS F-1) seen dockside at the Union Iron Works Shipyard in San Francisco. About six months later from this photo the Carp was making a test dive in San Francisco Harbor to 200 feet with a volunteer crew of eight men under the command of former Navy Lieutenant Simeon Burke Smith*.

The Normal process was to drop the under bow anchor to the bottom and submerge the submarine and adjust the sub to neutral buoyancy then haul the submarine down incrementally. Checking for leaks at stop points. When on the bottom at 200 feet the anchor jambed and the sub couldn't surface. A submarine would only be on the bottom for about ten minutes before surfacing. The men tried numbers of different procedures before breaking the sub free and made a dramatic broach at the surface with the bow high out of the water.

There are copies of the negative of this print that purport her to the the F-4.

The two large ocean liners in the background are the SS Ventura and the the SS Sonoma, both of which plied the US to Australia passenger trade.

Interesting trivia piece about the Ventura. In 1922 two Australians, friends from childhood, but they had lost track of each other. As children they had pledged to travel to America when they were older and were successful. They, independently, ended up booking second class cabins. (Which if you were a single passenger you shared with another person,) It ended up they had been both been booked to the same cabin.

*1909 2nd Submarine Flotilla for Submarine Instruction, to Command Cuttlefish (USS B-1) then USS Viper (USS B-2)
*1910 Commanding Officer USS Cuttlefish (USS B-1)
*1911 Commanding Officer USS Octopus (USS C-1)
*1912 Left Navy Service to Work for the Electric Boat Company, West Coast Division

Photo Contributed By Darryl Baker From the files of the Vallejo Naval & Historical Museum.


USS F-1
The USS F-1  (ex-Carp) SS 20 seen at Hawaii 1915.

USS F-1 aground
USS F-1 aground off Watsonville, Ca, Oct. 11, 1912
Two men were killed in the accident. F-1 was salvaged
only to later sink in a collision with her sister ship F-3.

Photo had been previously misidentified as the USS H-3.

USS F-1 aground
USS F-1 aground off Watsonville, Ca, Oct. 11, 1912
Photo had been previously misidentified as the USS H-3.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The above photo is the USS F-1 in Dry Dock at Mare Island, California circa March of 1914.

The men on the deck comprise about 1/3 of the crew. Tentative identifications have been made for three of the men.

On the left is a chief petty officer. He is believed to be Dudley Strough Chief Gunners Mate.

The man standing second from the right is believed to be Ray Elsworth Scott, Electricians Mate First class.

The chief seat in the center is thought to be John Peter Albert Messang, Chief Machinist's Mate.

These three men are known to have died in the sinking of the F-1 by ramming by the USS F-3 on Dec 17, 1917. The other men are yet to be identified.

The submarine in the dock with the F-1 should be the F-2 if this is the March 1914 dry docking.

To the right of the man on the right, below his arm, can be seen the number "1". The F-1 was the lead sub of the "1st" Pacific Submarine Squadron and had the numbers 1 over the number 1 on her conning tower fairwater. The placement of the conning tower ventilator and the shape of the forward periscope fairing confirm this is an "F" class submarine.

Original Photo In The Private Collection Of Ric Hedman


F-1 & F-4 moored to the starboard side of the USS Alert, San Pedro, Ca
F-1 & F-4 moored to the starboard side of the USS Alert, San Pedro, Ca.
The submarines were part of the First Submarine Group of the Pacific Torpedo Flotilla.
Photo circa; 1912 to 1914.

Postcard about F-1
Postcard written by a sailor assigned to the F-1 in March of 1913.
The card reads exactly as follows, misspellings an all:
San Dieago, Cal. March 1- 1913
Dear Dave
I tried to get out to see you before I left but as I shipped on the 13 - and at 10:PM I left for here - am asigned to the US Submarine F-1 for instructions 6 mon school. And if I make good a rate and one dollar a dive. Don't forget to write to a fellow ocasionally. Give my regards to the folks and many of my Best Wishes to Sis.
Your old Shipmate
J G Messary
(At the bottom of the card)
USS Submarine F-1 - SdC

USS F-1 at sea
USS F-1 on the way to California under tow.
A ships boat from the cruiser USS Maryland is bring supplies to the sub.
This was a routine that happened every few days during the tow.
The tug Iroquois, towing the USS F-2, is standing by in the background.
The remaining F-Boats were ordered back to the mainland after the F-4 sank.
Date November 5, 1915.

Photo provided by The Bowfin Museum

USS F-1 at sea
USS F-1 on the way to California under tow by the collier Nanshan.
Here the F-1 is hove-to and repairing her towing gear.
Date November 5, 1915.

Photo in the Private Collection of Ric Hedman

USS F-1 at sea
USS F-1 on the way to California under tow by the collier Nanshan.
Here the F-1 is hove-to and repairing her towing gear. Close-up view.
This photo shows the men on deck during the repair operation.
To better see the men I have shown their location with circles.
Date November 5, 1915.

Photo in the Private Collection of Ric Hedman

USS F-1 on the bottom
USS F-1 on the bottom off the California coast where she sank
after being rammed by the USS F-3 on Dec 17, 1917.
19 crew were lost in the ramming. First US war time loss of a
submarine it being during World War I. Accident happened 4 miles
West of La Jolla Light. This photo is one taken by the DSRV in 1986.

Photo provided by Rick Larson MMCM (SS) (ret.)

USS F-1 on the bottom
USS F-1 on the bottom. Photo was damaged sometime during its life.
Photo provided by Rick Larson MMCM (ret.)

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
Seen are the # 2 pericope sheer and the bridge access hatch. View from starboard side.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
Seen are the # 1 and # 2 pericope sheers and the bridge access hatch. View from port side.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
Seen is a deck access hatch. It is unclear if this is the forward or engine room hatch. View from port side.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
The forward running light stanchion and port bow diving plane.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
Hole caused by the bow of the USS F-3 in the side of the F-1 just aft of the main hatch. View from port side.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
Seen are the # 2 pericope sheer and the bridge access hatch. View from port side.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
Another view of the hole on the side of the F-1. View from port side.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
Starbord bow of the USS F-1. Hole for attaching the towing shackle can be seen.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
The USS F-1 resting on the bottom at 1453 feet deep after being rammed by the USS F-3.
Allied Signal Bell and damage to port superstructure.

Thanks to Steve Lawson of California Wreck Divers for these photos.


John Peter Albert Messang seen here in a newspaper photo provided by the family (L) after the F-1 had sank and an out take from a larger group photo (R) of the men from the USS F-1 and the USS F-4 taken at Pearl Harbor some time between January and March 1915.

Messang was married to Hulda Maria Klassy and had a son and a new daughter just a few months before the F-1 sinking. Messang joined the Navy in 1904 and had recently begun his fourth enlistment with the Navy at the time of the accident.

His wife and family received word of his death via a telegram from Admiral L. C. Palmer from the navy. The telegram said this; "The USS F-1 was rammed by another submarine at 7 p. m., Monday December 17, (1917) during a fog, the F-1 sinking immediately. It is with deepest regret that the bureau must convey to you the sad news that your husband, John P. A. Messang, chief machinist's mate, was lost in the sinking of the F-1.
"No additional information is at hand at this time. You have the sincere sympathy of the bureau in the loss of your husband."

The USS F-1 is the only submarine to be lost by the US during World War I.

Public Photos


USS F-2
F-2 and F-1 in dry dock
The USS F-2 and USS F-1 in dry dock. Date and location unknown but probably Mare Island.

USS F-2
The USS F-2 (ex-Barracuda) SS 21 at Honolulu Harbor c 1915.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-2 seen here on San Francisco Bay circa 1915/16 after the return to the US from Hawaii. The three remaining F-Class were ordered back to the mainland after the sinking of the USS F-4. The F-Class were replaced by the newer K-Class submarines.

In the background can be seen the early skyline and water front of San Francisco.

Original Photo in the Private Collection of Ric Hedman


USS F-2
USS F-2

USS F-2 off San Diego, Calf.
USS F-2 off San Diego, Calf.

USS F-2 and another F-boat
The USS F-2 and F-3 along side
the USS Alert, a submarine tender.
Location is Honolulu Harbor c1915.
The interned German cruise SMS Geier is moored in the background.


Homer 'Pat' Dilley
RM2 Homer 'Pat' Dilley aboard the USS F-2.
He is standing next to the #1 periscope shear facing aft.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Homer 'Pat' Dilley
RM2 Homer 'Pat' Dilley at his radio set aboard the USS F-2
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel
Some of the crew of the USS F-2 up on deck relaxing.
Boat on right is most likely the USS F-3.

Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

The crew size was 21 men and officers. These men represent the men 'Pat' Dilley sailed
with during his tour aboard the submarine. That is why there are more than 21 images here.

Chief Petty Officer Monk Cline

'Cheefoo' Ward

'Rats' Foshia

Chief Petty Officer
'Dizzy' Bill Williams

'Dopey' Walker

'Jazz' Brown

Homer 'Pat' Dilley


'Rabbit' Russell

C. I. Short

Phil Salvadore

D. T. Short

'Gay Cat' Van Natta


G. N. Tibbits

Louie Godbout


Chief Petty Officer
R. W. Nivison

'Sitting Bull' Smith

'Socks'

Tom Henry

Lt. Conant Taylor
CO USS F-2

Campbell

Williams

Harry LeRoy Corson

Schmidt

Grey

'Cheefoo' Ward

Blankenship

'Rabbit', 'Cheese' 'Gaycat'
Some of the crew of the USS F-2.
Photos courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Sub Base mascot Herman 'Jimmy Cheese' Reese
Herman 'Jimmy Cheese' Reese
This young man was the Sub Base mascot at San Pedro, California.
He was not a member of the US Navy but was allowed on the base.
Kind of a 'Big Brother' thing. He appears to be about 14 years of age.
Photos courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

USS F-2 in dry dock in Long Beach, California. No hull identification can be seen in this photo as is noted in a number of other photos taken after the submarine returned to the mainland from Hawaii.

View shows the Starboard bow with the bow cap turned to expose the #1 and #2 torpedo tubes. The tubes were numbered in an "X" design. #1 was the upper Starboard tube and #2 was the lower Port tube. Number #3 was the lower Starboard tube and #4 was the upper Port tube. Differing from the numbering modified after the rotating bow cap was done away with where the tubes were numbered from Starboard to Port and upper to lower, (Starboard)1,(Port)2,(Starboard)3,(Port)4, etc.

Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2. ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

USS F-2 showing a Stern view while in dry dock in Long Beach, California. Note the swinging braces attached to the dry dock wing walls for bracing larger vessels.

Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2. ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

USS F-2 bridge at sea. On the bridge, from left to right is the bridge lookout; Campbell, center is "Rats" Fohisa, who the helmsman and on the right, standing in front of the flag, is Lt. Conant Taylor, CO of the F-2. The projection on the right side is a portable 'head' for use on the surface since sanitary facilities below decks were crude to say the least. Mounted on the bridge is the signal lamp. Foreground left is the torpedo loading davit. Standing just to the right of the bridge fairwater on the back deck is a crewman, his legs and torso only are visible.

Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2. ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Some of the Gang
Some of the 'Gang' on the F-2.
Notice the tall man in the center, a CPO, and the man
to the right of him, not a CPO, have switched hats.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Some more of the 'gang'
L to R: 'Whan'; 'Anderson'; 'Rats' Fohisa, looking at the camera;
'Lewis', smoking the pipe and 'Pat' Dilley standing in the hatch.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Photo taken at sea June 1917
Photo taken at sea in June of 1917.
Projection to side of bridge is portable "head" for use on surface.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Some of the crew
Some of the crew posing for the camera. 'Pat' Dilley is on the far left.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

USS F-1, USS F-3 & USS F-2
USS F-1, USS F-3 and the USS F-2 rafted together. The USS F-4 sank in 1915.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

USS F-1, USS F-3 and USS F-2
USS F-1, USS F-3 and the USS F-2 rafted together.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

USS F-2 torpedo tubes
These are the USS F-2's four torpedo tubes. The "Business End" as they were called by the crew.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Some crew swimming off the stern at San Pedro
Three of the crew members of the F-2 swimming off the
stern of the F-2 at San Pedro submarine base.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Louie Godbout
Gay-Cat Van Natta, Ditty Box Rice, Rabbit Russell
Cheifie Johnston, Obie Short
George Tibbits, Homer 'Pat' Dilley
Top left: Louie Godbout   Top Right: Gay-Cat Van Natta, Ditty Box Rice & Rabbit Russell
Botton Left:  Cheifie Johnston & Obie Short   Bottom Right:  George Tibbits & Homer 'Pat' Dilley
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

Swim Party off the F-2 at San  Pedro, Ca
Ships gang plank is being used as a diving board rigged across the stern.
Photo courtesy of Mike Dilley; whose Father, Homer 'Pat' Dilley sailed aboard the USS F-2.

USS F-3
USS F-3 in frame, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock
USS F-3 in frame, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock November 3, 1909
Photo courtesy of Bill Lightfoot, author of Beneath The Surface.

USS F-3 with hull plates installed, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock
USS F-3 with hull plates installed, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock, circa 1910
Photo courtesy of Bill Lightfoot, author of Beneath The Surface.

USS F-3 near completion, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock
USS F-3 nearly finished. The rotating torpedo tube outer door casting
has been installed, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock, September 30, 1911

Photo courtesy of Bill Lightfoot, author of Beneath The Surface.

USS F-3 stern near completion, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock
USS F-3 stern nearly finished. circa 1911
Photo courtesy of Bill Lightfoot, author of Beneath The Surface.

USS F-3 stern finished, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock
USS F-3 stern finished. June 30, 1911
Photo courtesy of Bill Lightfoot, author of Beneath The Surface.

USS F-3 launch, Seattle Construction & Dry Dock
USS F-3 launch. January 6, 1912
Seattle PI Photo

Photo courtesy of Bill Lightfoot, author of Beneath The Surface.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 on Elliot Bay with Seattle in the background. The shed to the left of the periscope is the building shed at the Moran Brothers Shipyard where the F-3 was built. The F-3 is going to or has just made a trial dive. A skiff from the shipyard is standing by. The hill in the background is Beacon Hill to the south of Seattle.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 on Elliot Bay off the Seattle waterfront. The submarine is about to dive or has just surfaced from a trial dive. The yard crew making the ships trials can be seen on deck talking with the men in the skiff. Seen behind the submarine to the right is Queen Anne Hill north of the present day location of the Space Needle. To the left of the bridge fairing is Magnolia Bluff and West Point Lighthouse.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 on Elliot Bay off the Seattle waterfront. The submarine is about to dive or has just surfaced from a trial dive. The operation is aboservered by officials from the shipyard from a launch. A skiff is attending the submarine. Seen behind the submarine to the right is Queen Anne Hill north of the present day location of the Space Needle. Behind the periscopes is Magnolia Bluff and West Point Lighthouse.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 making her run North from Seattle up to Port Townsend, Wa for her trials there. Puget Sound is a little choppy. Barely seen through the spray is the Allied Signal Bell on the bow.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 making her run North from Seattle up to Port Townsend, Wa as seen from the bridge area. Puget Sound is a little choppy. Barely seen through the spray is the Allied Signal Bell on the bow.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The view looking aft on the USS F-3 on her run North from Seattle up to Port Townsend, Wa. The trademark white exhaust from the twin NELSECO diesels can be seen coming from the exhaust ports on either side of the hull below the flag staff.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Trial crew from the Moran Shipyard pose on the bow while on the trip North to Port Townsend, Wa. The headland seen on the left is Point No Point on the Kitsap Pennisula. The man closest to the camera is Julius Francis Rausch Jr, an employee of the Moran Shipyard and original owner of these family photos.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The F-3 moored to a dock on the Port Townsend waterfront. The town has changed little since this photo was taken in 1912. Most all of the buildings you see here are still in use today. The framework for the canvas bridge cover can be seen in this photo. An unidentified chief petty officer is seen on the bridge structure.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The F-3 backs away from a dock on the Port Townsend waterfront. She is doing this on battery power since the diesel engines are direct drive and only go forward.The canvas bridge cover has been erected on the pipe framework at this time. In the background is seen the north end of Marrowstone Island across Port Townsend Bay. View is looking south.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The F-3 having backed away from a dock at Port Townsend sits on the Bay. In the background is seen the north end of Marrowstone Island to the left and on the right is Indian Island across Port Townsend Bay. View is looking south.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The F-3 running the measured mile off Indian Island. The trial crew are using various instruments and stop watches to run the course. Seen in the distance is the Kitsap Pennisula and Port Townsend. The view is looking north.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The F-3 running the measured mile off Indian Island. The trial crew are logging information from the stop watches. The second man from the right is Julius Francis Rausch Jr. Seen in the distance is the Kitsap Pennisula and Port Townsend. The view is looking north.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 on Port Townsend Bay for her performance trials. Behind is the U.S. Revenue Cutter Rush and a four masted schooner. circa June 15, 1912. Port Townsend is a town about 30 miles north of Seattle.

Photo from the Jefferson County Historical Society


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 on Port Townsend Bay for her performance trials. The view is looking almost due West. circa June 15, 1912. Port Townsend is a town about 30 miles north of Seattle.

Photo from the Jefferson County Historical Society


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

A close-up view of the photo above. The USS F-3 on Port Townsend Bay for her performance trials. circa June 15, 1912. The view is looking almost due West. Port Townsend is a town about 30 miles north of Seattle.

Photo from the Jefferson County Historical Society


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 doing submerging trials on Port Townsend Bay as part of her performance trials. There appears to be two men still on the top of the conning tower so a full dive is not anticipated. circa June 15, 1912.

Photo from the Jefferson County Historical Society


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 doing submerging trials on Port Townsend Bay as part of her performance trials. There appears to be two men still on the top of the conning tower so a full dive is not anticipated. circa June 15, 1912.

Photo from the Jefferson County Historical Society


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The bow of the F-3 seen as the submarine enters the Bremerton Naval Yard for a spell in the Dry Dock. Probably before commissioning and heading to San Francisco.

Seen in the background several Armored Cruisers are moored in the yard. It is a good possibility that they are the USS Pennsylvania AC-4 and the USS Charleston CA-19 of the Pacific Reserve Fleet and also served as a receiving ship at Puget Sound from November 4, 1912 to January 10, 1916. Pennsylvania was at Bremerton having her foremast changed out and replaced by the new "Cage" mast. The second Cage mast in unknown. Charleston is between them.

The Floating Derrick was constructed at Mare Island and was of the same design and construction, only just a little bit smaller than the one they had constructed to go to Pearl Harbor.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.
Thanks to Darryl Baker for confirming location.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Ensign Kenneth Heron, Commanding Officer of the F-3 sits on the Starboard Bow Plane of the F-3 while in Dry Dock most likely in the Bremerton Navy Yard.

The Torpedo Bow Cap is rotated as to open the top starboard and bottom port tubes. In the closed position the openings would have lined up behind the bow stem.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

This photo shows the stern of the F-3 just after the Dry Dock has been pumped up. The the movable 'wing' supports are bracing the submarine until the more permanent timber bracing is put in place.

A man on deck can be seen with loosely coiled heaving line in his hand no doubt just used in the mooring process in docking the submarine. Several stray timbers are in the water.Probably having floated off the submerged dock. Actually by comparison with the next photo you can see that the dock has not been fully pumped out at this point with the dock floor still awash.

Note the pipe cagework around the Conning Tower. This structure was the frame that held the weather canvases in place making a more enclosed area for the Officers and men needing to be topside while underway. Just the bridge structure offered no protection from the elements.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Workmen standing and working on the stern planes of the F-3 while in Dry Dock at the Bremerton Naval Yard. At this point the Dry Dock has been fully pumped out and the floor of the dock is fully available.

Photo is from the Private Family Collection of Mitchell Noll ~ NOT a Public Domain Image.


USS F-3 off Diamond Head, Hawaii
The USS F-3 (ex-Pickeral) SS 22 underway off Diamond Head, Territory of Hawaii

Crew of F-3 standing on deck
Crew of F-3 standing on deck. Note on the back of the photo states:
"The crew of the F-3 in their heavy weather togs.
I am the 12th from the forward end of the boat"
This photo was owned by a crewman or sent to family or friends from the person.

Superstructure of F-3
A good close-up of the superstructure of F-3 showing periscopes and radio mast.

F-3 Captain & Executive officer
F-3 Captain & Executive officer

F-3 chief petty officers
F-3 chief petty officers

F-3 Crew
F-3 Crew.
The man on the right is the one who made the notations on the original photo.

F-3 Crew
F-3 Crew

F-3 Crew
F-3 Crew

Workmen working on the F-3 while crew photo is being taken
Workmen working on the F-3 while crew photo is being taken

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-2 and F-3 in the Inter Island Dry Dock in Honolulu Harbor. The salvaged submarine F-4 was moved from this dry dock and taken to Pearl Harbor and left on the bottom in Magazine Loch for future disposal to get these two submarines into it. The F-2 took the brunt of the collision with the USS Supply when she lost power while trying to maneuver into the pier along side the submarines. The two subs are bow to bow. The F-3 is in the rear and the F-2 is closest to the camera.

See News Paper Stories below for details.

Photo from the Private Collection of Ric Hedman


Honolulu Star Bulletin, September 1915

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Honolulu Star Bulletin, September 1915


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

USS F-3 seen in Honolulu Harbor c1915. The view is looking directly out the channel to the Pacific Ocean. The sunlight in the photo indicates that the photo was taken in the morning as the sunlight is coming from the east in the photo. This would make it a return from a morning diving exercise same as the one the F-4 never returned from. Sand Island would be off the right side of the photo.

The torpedo loading hatch is open so she may be returning from torpedo practice and the retrieved torpedo is below.

Mooring lines are being straightened out on deck as the submarine prepares to dock. A chief petty officer stands on the bow, possibly the C.O.B. (Chief Of the Boat).

In the background to the left is the Honolulu Harbor coaling station for ships to replenish their coal supply. The large building behind the submarine is known as the "Channel Wharf". A commercial dock that shows a ship moored almost directly behind the torpedo loading ramp.

The date is probably prior to March 25, 1915 when the F-4 sank. After that date the submarines were ordered to make no more dives. This would have probably ended most normal functions for the remaining class of submarines. Though they did provide assistance during the salvage operations.

Photo from the Private Collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 seen here in Honolulu Harbor, Sand Island is in the background. The submarine seems to be coming into a mooring to the Navy leased pier 5A. Crew are standing on deck with heaving lines in hand and mooring lines on deck. The subs gangplank is seen laying crosswise over the deck just aft of the conning tower fairwater. On the bridge, behind the periscope in his white uniform, is Lieut.(jg) Francis W Scanland the F-3 commanding Officer. He relieved Lieut. Leo F Welch in April 1915 who had brought the F-3 to Hawaii.

Seen to the extreme right is the USS F-2 moored to the submarine tender USS Alert AS-4, who is, in turn, moored to pier 5. On the side of the F-2 conning tower fairwater you can see a number "1" over the number "2". This means the vessel is part of the Pacific Submarine Division 1 and the subs name is "2" meaning F-2. Between the two submarines is a man on a raft, called a paint float, no doubt positioning it to do some hull upkeep before the subs were to head to San Francisco.

The low laying land in the background is known to be Sand Island as the few trees and features on this man made island are easily identifiable when compared to the background in the third photo from the top of this page. This took some time since neither the Honolulu Harbor Light Station or the Quarantine Dock is visible in this photo.

The photos' dating is fairly easily defined by the presence of the tender Alert which did not arrive at Honolulu until mid-October 1915 with the replacement submarines K-2, K-4, K-7 and K-8 for the returning F-Class. The three F-Boats left Hawaii on October 31, 1915, in tow, by the tug USS Iroquois, the collier USS Nanshan AG-3 and the Armored Cruiser USS Maryland ACR-8 who took charge of the F-3. All destined for Mare Island Shipyard, all three for extensive overhauls before being allowed to dive again.

Photo from the Private Collection of Ric Hedman



Over the years we at PigBoats.COM have discovered numerous photos that have been misidentified. Sometimes it was through lack of knowledge or information. Sometimes it was through making a guess as to who or what the photo was about or who was the subject of the photo.

Such is the case with these two following images. Both implied that the right hand submarine was the Ill-fated USS F-4. The two photos were taken with in days of each other because the inboard boats is obviously the same in both photos though the details of the USS F-3 have changed over the ensuing days. The bow has been painted and the towing bridle has been added to the submarine.



Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

A photo taken prior to October 31, 1915 sailing shows the F-3 and an unidentified submarine moored to pier 5 in Honolulu Harbor. The Honolulu Light Station building can be seen in the background.

An unidentified crewman stands on the deck talking to someone on a dock or possibly another submarine barely seen at the edge of the photo. The shape of the bow planes cover on the unknown submarine needs to match the ones on the F-3 to be the F-4. They don't match.

At the left edge of the photo are several people in a skiff rowing around the harbor and looking at the submarines maybe talking to the crewman barely seen standing behind the bridge fairwater. His crooked arm is seen seemingly hand on hip. A light wind from the south is blowing the crews washing hung from a jackline strung between a spar and the bridge. The bow of the F-3 is badly scuffed. The scaring on the bow of the right hand submarine matches in both photos.


Photo in the Private Collection of Cory Graff, Author of "The Navy In Puget Sound"


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 and an unidentified F-Class submarine moored to Pier 5 in Honolulu Harbor. The photo is suppose to be the F-3 and F-4. Both the F-3 and F-4 were Seattle built boats so, according to other photos evidence the bow planes covers should match. These do not match.

Note the towing yoke attached to the bow of the F-3. Just such a configuration is seen at the bow of the F-3 as she was picking up her tow lines on October 31, 1915 from the Cruiser Maryland which was to tow her to San Francisco. These boats not having the fuel capacity to quite make such a trip on their own. You will notice that the scuffing on the bow of the F-3, so evident in the above photo has now been painted implying a later photographic time frame.

Honolulu Harbor is a commercial harbor and had all sorts of access to the public in the early years hence civilians on the pier. At the far right is what seems to be the Tender Alert. If this is the Alert the photo had to be taken after its arrival in Honolulu in mid-October of 1915. If that is the case this photo was taken within days of the submarines leaving Hawaii.

Seen in the background is the Honolulu Harbor Light Station on Sand Island at the inner end of the harbor entrance.

Navy Photo


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

USS F-3 outside Pearl Harbor waiting to pick up her tow-line for the tow back to the mainland. After the sinking of the F-4 the F class subs were replaced by the newer K-class of submarines. The subs were towed because they didn't have the range to make it on their own and were prone to break downs.

The F-3 is flying several signal flags. It looks like the camera caught the flags in mid change. The flag closest to the camera is the "C" or "Charlie" flag meaning "Yes" or "Affirmative", it seems to be in the process of being hoisted.. The flag in the rear and partly blocked by the Charlie flag but looks to be the "J" or "Juliet" flag meaning "I am going to send a message by semaphore", it seems to be in mid-process of being lowered. These are most likely in response to flag signals from the Cruiser Maryland who is in the process of taking her in tow.

The towing bridle can be seen attached to a large pin placed through the bow just above the waterline at the bow. The men are waiting to receive a shotline from the Maryland that would be attached to a heavier line that would have been, yet, attached to a towing cable that would require this number of men to just haul it aboard. As it was, half way through the tow, this heavy line parted and needed to be brought aboard again. The F-3 was cast off from the tow off the mouth to San Francisco Bay to make her way in on her own power.

Photo from the Private Collection of Ric Hedman.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 sailing through the Golden Gate November 11, 1915 after a very rough 15 day tow behind the USS Maryland. These submarines didn't have the "legs" to make a 2100 mile passage with their own fuel reserves plus engine breakdowns were a normal occurrence. They were very much still coastal vessels. The Maryland had escorted 4 "K" class submarines to Honolulu to replace the remaining "F" boats that had been recalled to the mainland as a result of the scandal in the wake of the F-4 sinking.

Behind the bridge of the submarine, barely seen on top of the point of land is the Bonita Point lighthouse. the north headland of the entrance through the Golden Gate. The body of water behind the submarines bridge and to the left of the darker headland is Bonita Cove.

On the left on the bridge, one of the two men may be the Commanding Officer, Lt.(jg) Francis W. Scanland. On the right, an enlisted man has the helm. The unusual canvas object protruding from the side of the bridge is a "head", a toilet system to be used while at sea on the surface. These submarines had rudimentary on-board toilet systems.

Photo from the Private Collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 sailing through the Golden Gate November 11, 1915. On the left on the bridge, one of the two men may be the Commanding Officer, Lt.(jg) Francis W. Scanland. On the right, an enlisted man has the helm. The unusual canvas object protruding from the side of the bridge is a "head", a toilet system to be used while at sea on the surface. These submarines had rudimentary on-board toilet systems.

Photo from the Private Collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-3 sailing through the Golden Gate November 11, 1915. The crew seem to be enjoying some nice weather after a very rough 15 day tow behind the USS Maryland. There was no Golden Gate Bridge at this time just the harbor headlands.

Photo from the Private Collection of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Chief Petty Officer Peacock posing for this photo on the deck of the USS F-3 aft of the bridge fairwater. Chief Peacock's rate is as a Chief Yeoman, a man who handled the subs clerical administrative duties and paperwork. There are two other submarines behind him, the classes and ID of the vessels is unknown. Photo circa 1916.

Photo from the Private Collection of Ric Hedman


Uss F-3 tied up inboard of the USS H-3
USS F-3 tied up inboard of the USS H-3
Photo courtesy of Carolyn Fields Snider whose Uncle, Harry Fields took the photos or is in them.

USS F-4
USS F-4
The USS F-4 (ex-Skate) SS 23
March 25, 1915 the USS F-4 sank with all hands lost off Honolulu, Territory of Hawaii

USS F-4
The USS Skate (F-4) SS 23 in frame at the Moran Ship yard November 3, 1909.
The view is from the starboard bow.

USS F-4
The USS Skate (F-4) SS 23 in frame at the Moran Ship yard November 3, 1909.
The view is from the starboard beam.

USS F-4
The USS Skate (F-4) SS 23 at the Moran Ship yard.
The view is the same as above but taken on January 3, 1910. A good part of the hull plate has been attached.

USS F-4
The USS Skate (F-4) SS 23 stern view at the Moran Ship yard June 10, 1910.
To the left in the photo, between the wood support members, you can see the rudder and stern planes casting in place.
A Moran shipyard worker looks at the photographer as the photo is taken.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-4 during Inclining Test at the Moran Shipyard in Seattle Washington. The date is unknown but most likely circa March 1913.

Photo from the Family Collection of Mitchell Noll


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-4, March 13, 1913, ran aground on the south side of the West Point Light House, Magnolia Bluff in the background. En-route to Port Townsend for trials the Commanding Officer, Lt. Simeon Burke Smith*, explained it as a mis-judgement in steering that caused the grounding. A tug was called and the sub pulled free. It was determined there was no damage and proceeded to Port Townsend.

It must be understood that at this time in our submarine history that boats were manned by civilian yard crews and had nominal navy presence aboard while the submarine was put through its paces. Once the sub was approved for acceptance by the Navy, then Naval crews took over.

*Captain Smith was a former Navy submarine Captain and left the Navy in March of 1912 to take a position with Electric Boat Company as a trial Officer. He travelled to shipyards building Electric Boat submarines to conduct their Sea Trials prior to Navy acceptance.

Photo from the Family Collection of Mitchell Noll


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Photo printed in the Seattle Post Intelligencer Newspaper of March 14th 1913 showing the F-4 aground on West Point, just northwest of down town Seattle. To the left in the photo you can see under the submarines bow that her mushroom anchor has been dropped. A ladder it seems has been brought out from the West Point lighthouse to allow the captain, Lt. Simeon Burke Smith, to climb down and call for a tug using the telephone from the lighthouse. She was subsequently pulled of the beach on the next high tide by the tug Pioneer from the Puget Sound Tug Boat Company.

Photo from the Seattle Post Intelligencer Archive


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Another photo printed in the Seattle Post Intelligencer Newspaper of March 14th 1913 showing the F-4 aground on West Point, just northwest of down town Seattle. To the left in the photo you can see under the submarines bow that her mushroom anchor has been dropped. A ladder it seems has been brought out from the West Point lighthouse to allow the captain, Lt. Simeon Burke Smith, to climb down and call for a tug using the telephone from the lighthouse. She was subsequently pulled of the beach on the next high tide by the tug Pioneer from the Puget Sound Tug Boat Company.

Photo from the Seattle Post Intelligencer Archive


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-4, moored outboard the USS Davis, Torpedo Boat 12 and USS Fox, Torpedo Boat 13 at Port Townsend, Washington. Which is which I can't tell from this photo. I remember coastal steamers like the one in the background from my earliest days on Puget Sound as a child.

Photo from the Family Collection of Mitchell Noll


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-4, making a 200 foot dive in Seattle Harbor, (Elliott Bay). West Seattle can be seen in the background, circa April 1913 after returning from trials on Port Townsend Bay.

The process was to make a shallow dive, like seen in this photo, achieve a neutral buoyancy and then drop the mushroom anchor housed under the bow to the bottom and slowly winch the submarine down to depth. Twenty-four hours later the sub returned to the surface. All through her trials the F-4 was plagued by numerous failures of mechanical systems but these were considered "normal and acceptable" for that time. The F-4 was commissioned May 3, 1913 in Seattle with Ens. Kirkwood Donovin Commanding and the illfated Ens. Alfred Ede as XO. He was to perish as the F-4 Commanding Officer with the rest of the F-4 crew two years later off Honolulu Harbor.

Photo from the Family Collection of Mitchell Noll


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

This news paper photo was taken prior to the F-4 sailing to San Pedro then Hawaii. All but two of the men shown here were on that fateful last dive. They had already been transferred off the F-4 and sent to other vessels. They almost all seem to be puffing on cigars.

The man highest in the photo, center, is Earnest Cauvin. It isn't known if the dog held by Edwin Hill is his own dog or the dog may have been the subs mascot or even if it was the mascot if it was aboard on that last dive.

Image provided by: Penn State University Libraries; University Park, PA
Evening Public Ledger, March 31, 1915


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

This photo of the USS F-4 was taken in San Pedro or maybe San Diego Harbor prior to flotilla's departure to Hawaii.

The man at the top of the mast is Electricians Mate 2nd Class George L Deeth. He may have just been goofing off but more likely he had been checking the light at the mast head. Running lights falling under his job classification. Proof of this identification comes from the Deeth family archives that show a very poor quality version of this same photo.

The photo had been previously ID'd by Dave Johnston as possibly being the F-4. I wasn't convinced. Seems he was correct in his analysis of the image. Thanks Dave.

Original Photo In Private Collection Of Ric Hedman


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

This photo of the USS F-4 was taken in San Pedro or maybe San Diego Harbor prior to flotilla's departure to Hawaii.

The man at the top of the mast is Electricians Mate 2nd Class George L Deeth. His facial features match other known images of him.

Original Photo In Private Collection Of Ric Hedman


USS F-4 and another F-boat
The USS F-4 and another F-class submarine dockside.
The unidentified boat is probably the F-2 or F-3 since the F-1 had a large
dome on her deck. Notice the spar bouys stacked on the dock.
The back of the card reads;
"Here is a picture of the Submarine
F4 which sank in the harbor here, with 21 men on board. I suppose
you read about it in the papers. The Maryland is here now getting it up."


These Crew Photos Have Been Contributed To The COMSUBPAC Page About The F-4
Crew of the F-4
George T. Ashcroft,GM1 Clark G. Buck, GM2 Ernest C. Cauvin, MM2 Harley Colwell, EMC
Walter F.Covington,MM1 George L. Deeth, EM1 Alfred L. Ede, LT (CO) Frederick Gilman, GM1
Aliston H. Grindle,EMC Frank N. Herzog, EM2 Edwin S. Hill, MM1 Francis M. Hughson,MM1
Albert F. Jennie, EM2 Archie H. Lunger, GM2 Ivan L. Mahan, MM1 Horace L. Moore, GM1
William S. Nelson, MMC Timothy Parker,Ens( XO) Frank C. Pierard, GMC Charles H. Wells, MM2
Henry A. Withers, GM1
LT Alfred L. Ede Commanding Officer
LT Alfred L. Ede, Commanding Officer
Harley Colwell EMC
Harley Colwell EMC
Edwin S. Hill, MM1
Edwin S. Hill, MM1
George L. Deeth, EM1
George L. Deeth, EM1
Frank C. Pierard, GMC
Frank C. Pierard, GMC
Francis M. Hughson,MM1
Francis M. Hughson,MM1
Archie H. Lunger, GM2
Archie H. Lunger, GM2 
George T. Ashcroft, GM1
George T. Ashcroft, GM1
Clark G. Buck, GM2
Clark G. Buck, GM2
Ernest C. Cauvin, MM1
Ernest C. Cauvin, MM1
Walter F. Covington, MM1
Walter F. Covington, MM1
Frederick Gilman, GM1
Frederick Gilman, GM1
Aliston H. Grindle, C Elect.
Aliston H. Grindle, C Elect.
Frank H. Herzog, ET2
Frank H. Herzog, ET2
Albert F. Jennie, ET2
Albert F. Jennie, ET2
Ivan L. Mahan, MM1
Ivan L. Mahan, MM1
Horace L. Moore, GM1
Horace L. Moore, GM1
William S. Nelson, MMC
William S. Nelson, MMC
Ensign Timothy A. Parker, XO
Ensign Timothy A. Parker, XO
Charles H. Wells, MM2
Charles H. Wells, MM2
Henry A. Withers, GM1
Henry A. Withers, GM1

Mixed crews of submariners on deck of F boat
This photo of submarine crews contains six men from the ill-fated USS F-4. The photo appears to have been taken on the deck of the F-1 since she shows an object on her deck like the one in front of George L. Deeth, EM1 second man from right. The weapons loading davit appears to be the same in shape and location as in other "F" class photos. There is another "F" class submarine in the photo just behind the men. Between Chief Colwell and the man in the old fashioned bathing suit can be seen part of a torpedo loading ramp. Behind the head of the second man from left, Archie H. Lunger, GM2, is the forward periscope fairing. The after periscope faring is behind the man on the far left. The bridge access trunk can be seen between the two periscopes. Photo taken prior to March 25, 1915.

Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Newspaper photo posted in the Denver Post on March 29, 1915 showing three USS F-4 crewmen posing for the camera.

The man on the left is believed to be Edwin Hill Machinest Mate 1/C. In the center is Chief Electrician Harley Colwell and Gunnersmate 2/C Clark George Buck at the right.

Photo from the Family Collection of George Myers who is a distant cousin of Clark Buck


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

Four members of the F-4 crew going on "...shore leave...". Newspaper photo posted in the Denver Post on March 29, 1915.

This photo tells us a bit about the possible relationships aboard the submarine. Who the the different men associated with. Who you "...hit the beach with..." It was a small crew but still men made choices of who they hung out with. The newspaper may have just asked the 4 to stand together for the photo but it is also possible they were a group heading out together.

The man on the left is thought to be Albert F Jennie, Electricians Mate 2/Class of Festus, MO. Chief Electrician Harley Colwell from Seattle, WA is next in his uniform. Based on the single hash-mark on his left sleeve he had less than 8 years in the Navy at the time of this photo. The third man is believed to be Horace L Moore, Gunners Mate 1st/Class of Philadelphia, PA. The man on the right is Clark George Buck Gunners Mate 2/C from Tacoma, WA.

So, in 1915 is this is the way submarine sailors "Hit the Beach" for Liberty? Looking pretty dashing in the suits, ties and straw hats!

Photo from the Family Collection of George Myers who is a distant cousin of Clark Buck


Hold Mouse Over Image
To Scroll the Image Use Mouse Wheel

The USS F-4 backing away from her slip in Honolulu Harbor. The date is unknown but this is pretty much as she would have looked on the morning of March 25, 1915 when she left for her last dive taking all of her crew aboard to their deaths.

The Quarantine Dock is seen in the background with a ship and a barge. This is believed to be the Interred German Cruiser SMS Geier. The barges are probably delivering coal to the Geier. Several other vessels are anchored to the left of the Quarantine dock.

On top of the conning tower the helmsman's right shoulder and arm are just seen to the left of the forward periscope. The man at the bow has a large deck wrench. Probably used to secure deck hatches. The man forward of the conning tower is probably checking that all is secure. A larger group of men gather on the aft deck in preparation to dropping below through the engine room hatch.

It was common practice with these submarines to actually submerge in the harbor and travel out the channel with just the periscopes showing. This is how the F-4 was last seen by the F-2 before she went to the bottom with all hands.

Image from the Maritime Museum of San Diego


Click To View The F-4 Salvage Operations

Read / Sign our Deck Log


Holland | A-Boats | B-Boats | C-Boats | D-Boats | E-Boats | F-Boats |
| G-Boats | H-Boats | K-Boats | L-Boats | M-Boats | N-Boats | O-Boats |
| R-Boats | S-Boats | T-Boats | V-Boats |Simon Lake Subs| The Fleet Boats |
| Wilkins-Ellsworth Expedition | Home |

Page created by:
Ric Hedman 1999 - 2013©
PigBoats.COMTM
Mountlake Terrace,WA
webmaster@PigBoats.COM
The author is a Member of The HTML Writers Guild
The HTMLWriters Guild